Zoning, Affordability, and COVID-19
July 15, 2020 by admin
Housing, Land Use, Policy/Legislative
Housing Affordability & Single-Family Zoning
A recent piece by none other than Chuck Maron (founder of Strong Towns) published in, of all places, The American Conservative, brings back to the fore the recent debate about doing away with exclusive zones for single-family homes to, among other things, deal with the housing affordability crisis. Titled It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning, Mahron makes the argument that exclusive zoning for single-family homes is not a conservative political principle, but is rather exactly the opposite, he says:
“…the suburbs would go away because they can’t exist without excessive and ongoing federal subsidy.
The progressive left has discovered that single-family zoning has racist underpinnings. That’s great, because we should now have no problem finding common cause for repealing this most distorting of regulations, one that the federal government never should have forced cities to adopt to begin with.
In fact, the conservative thing for suburban leaders to do here is to not wait for the federal government to tempt us with more handouts, but to go ahead and show those progressives running the big cities that we live by our principles, that we embrace vibrant markets and free people, by preemptively repealing single-family zoning.”
Several local and state governments around the country have, within the last year or so, undertaken moves to ban or severely restrict the use of exclusive single-family zoning, among them Minneapolis, Seattle, Toronto, and the State of Oregon. There have been some very interesting and thought-provoking writings on this topic recently as well, most notably It’s Time to End Single-Family Zoning in the Journal of APA, and a recent opinion piece by Carol Galante in the New York Times.
Here in Utah, the housing affordability issue provoked actions such as a housing affordability task force headed up by Lt. Governor Spencer Cox, and the subsequent creation of the Commission on Housing Affordability by the state legislature. The business community also acted with the creation of the Housing Gap Coalition. Early on, there was talk at the legislative and business community levels about restrictions or stipulations on local land use regulations to encourage the production of more housing, under the theory that more housing supply would lead to better affordability (the supply-and-demand principle). But local officials pushed back indicating that the major issues with housing affordability were the costs of labor, materials and land, not so much land use controls.
Subsequent work by these various groups led to the crafting and passage of bills by the legislature that would not so much mandate or restrict local land use controls, but rather link land use outcomes to state funding for transportation, and to policy outcomes for mandated moderate-income housing plans, most notably SB136 in the 2018 session and HB34 in the 2019 session. Despite some early threats, Utah did not follow the path set by some places around the country (noted above) to restrict use of single-family zones.
Housing Affordability and COVID-19
So, what has happened with the housing affordability issue subsequently, and with the impact from COVID-19 and associated economic recession?
Cameron Diehl, executive director of the Utah League of Cities and Towns, gives a summary of local government actions that have been undertaken subsequent to the requirements of SB136 and HB34 by local governments around the state, which show an increasing move toward diversification in land use regulations. In particular, the trend toward adoption of ordinances to permit Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs), mixed use, and transit oriented developments (TODs) are prominent. Is this making a difference?
A recent report by the Kem C. Gardner Institute shows that new construction last year and so far this year are closing the gap in housing (creation of new households v. construction of new housing units), which is good news, but Michael Parker of Ivory Co. notes that at the current rate, it would take 33 years to close the gap completely. New construction is indeed up, but Mike Ostermiller of the Northern Wasatch Association of Realtors noted in a recent ULI Utah panel discussion that this July, there are some 6400 homes for sale listed in the Multiple Listing Service, whereas typically in July in past years the number has been closer to 10,000. Chris Gamvroulas, President of Ivory Development, also on the ULI panel, said that typically Ivory has about 30% of its new home sales referred by realtors. Right now it is closer to 60%, indicating that homebuyers are having a hard time finding homes to buy. While all this bodes well for the housing market, the industry is having a hard time keeping up, and such indicators usually mean increasing housing prices.
A story in last week’s issue of The Economist recalled that during most recessions, housing markets usually suffer because of hits to rent and mortgage payers’ ability to cover their housing costs. However, the story notes, the COVID recessions is behaving “oddly” – housing markets are not tanking.
“…researchers noted before the pandemic that the supply of new housing in America was failing to keep up with demand—owing in part to increasingly complex land regulations and reduced competition in house-building. Social-distancing requirements are also likely to hold construction back in the coming months. With supply constrained and demand boosted, house prices seem to rest on solid foundations.”
So it appears that the current recession is not having the expected moderating effect on the housing market and thus, affordability. So what is likely to happen on the land use regulation scene upcoming?
Cameron Diehl, in a presentation to the Housing Gap Coalition meeting on July 10, said that action by local and state officials has been focusing on fleshing out the ramifications for Transportation Investment Corridors outlined in SB136. This year’s League conference will pay attention to this issue, much as recent past League meetings focused on SB34.
However, Chris Gamvroulas, a member of the Commission on Housing Affordability, indicated that he has been charged by the Commission with chairing a subcommittee of Commission members to look at land use issues in housing affordability. Chris said in the Housing Gap Coalition webcast that he anticipates that there will be serious consideration given to the role of local land use regulation, with possible substantial legislative changes.
Single-family zoning, anyone?
Written by: Wilf Sommerkorn
Recent News
- Brainstorming: Ukraine’s Post War Reconstruction
- How a new website may influence Wasatch Mountain planning
- CLAMOR IS KING –PART II
- Let’s Change the Process to Change Our Zoning: A Response to State and Federal Zoning Controls
- Awards Spotlight: Utah Valley Visioning
- Award Spotlight: Mid Valley ATP
- Award Spotlight: Interlocal Sustainability Action Plan
- Award Spotlight: South Salt Lake General Plan Update
- Hey, Utahns—stop driving your car
- Award Spotlight: 2020 Kearns General Plan and Resilience + Infrastructure Element
- Art as Daily Experience in Ogden’s Nine Rails Creative District
- Award Spotlight: Salt Lake City Reimagines Nature
- LET’S TALK! AND TALK. AND TALK SOME MORE…
- A Minnesota Judge Throws the Book at Immoral Tax Assessments
- The Great Rebalance
- To Fully Observe, We Need to Walk
- Study reveals that Utah housing prices have increased 200% in two decades
- DOUBLE WHAMMY
- The Office of the Property Rights Ombudsman
- Gov. Cox hails ‘generational’ effort in Utah’s water law history
- Clamor is King
- Utah Is Building a ’15-Minute City’ From Scratch
- Quality of Life – A Dishonest Approach to Change in Neighborhood Character
- Changing the Rules of Zoning
- Growth & Change In the West: 2022 RMLUI Conference Recap
- Vernacular Is Beautiful—If We Would Just Allow It
- APAUT Spring Conference Follow-up and Pictures
- To Airbnb or Not to Airbnb
- The Costs of Wide Streets in the U.S.
- APAUT President’s Message – March 2022
- How should we decide the fate of Utah Lake?
- How the Utah Legislature continues to usurp power from city and county government
- What to know about residential care facilities in your neighborhood
- University of Utah Professor Named the 3rd Most Cited Planning Faculty in the World
- TWO BIG BILLS OUT
- Examining the Impact of London’s Mandatory Inclusionary Housing
- May We all Grow Together: Cultivating Support for Utah’s Emerging Planners
- A Commitment to Change
- Okay Boomer
- APAUT Book Discussion: Evicted by Matthew Desmond
- Economic Development After the Rise of Telework
- Follow the 2022 Legislative Session
- After the Bennett Freeze: Planning Within the Navajo Nation
- Flexible Zoning for the New Economy
- Lead and Inspire with Purpose: AICP Code of Ethics Update
- Janet Quinney Lawson – Institute for Land, Water & Air
- Emerging Planners Survey
- Plan to restore Utah Lake met with resistance from Utah County conservation groups
- New Murray projects and guidelines move forward as moratorium ends
- From the Office of Dodge, Wiggle, Hack, Shrug & DeCamp, LLC
- Land Use Training
- Paul Allred: Career Reflections & Valuable Advice – Part 3
- Cache Summit 2021
- WAVE HIKING PERMIT CHANGES ON THE WAY
- Paul Allred: Career Reflections & Valuable Advice (Part 2)
- Paul Allred: Career Reflections & Valuable Advice
- UDOT seeks public input on rural Utah transportation plans
- Electric Vehicles Are on the Rise. Is Your Community Ready?
- Call for Award Nominations
- Fifteen-Minute City
- Remember Olympia Hills?
- The Mountain Lions: these nine cities boomed in the COVID era
- AS PLANNERS, WHY DO WE DO WHAT WE DO, AND WHY ARE WE DOING IT?
- Andrea Garfinkel-Castro, doctoral candidate, “Unpacks” Latino Urbanism
- 11 Ways To Excel Ethically At Every Level
- Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD): core principles
- A Tale of Two Walks: Part 2
- Heat, Health & Equity: The Effects of High Temperatures on Health, and Ways to Mitigate Heat in Our City
- Help Shape Equity Planning Policy
- DO CITIES HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO BAN FIREWORKS?
- Air Quality Is Better In Utah Today Than Ten Years Ago, But…
- Layton council adopts water-saving landscaping requirements for most new development
- CAREFUL WHOM YOU CALL A NIMBY
- Considering A National Infrastructure Bank
- HEALTHY UTAH COMMUNITY
- Breaking Down Silos: The Inception of the Utah Rural Coordinating Council
- MAG Transit Studies
- Effective Public Engagement Requires a Lot More Than a Public Hearing
- Is Remote Work Here to Stay?
- SENSITIVE LANDS PLANNING: PROTECTING PUBLIC HEALTH, SAFETY, AND WELFARE FOR GENERATIONS TO COME
- Bond Ratings are for Investors (Not Taxpayers)
- It’s Complicated (Ok, you’ve heard that before, but maybe not for this topic – billboards.)
- The Color of Law APAUT Online Book Discussion
- The American Jobs Plan Will Make Our Infrastructure Crisis Worse
- President’s Infrastructure Proposal Includes Addressing Housing Affordability
- We Cannot Plan from Our Desks
- Rep. Curtis, Sen. Romney introduce bill to advance the Bonneville Shoreline Trail
- Utah could lose out on billions in federal funding for passenger rail
- The Cure for the Wasatch Front’s Housing Crisis: More Affordable Homes Between North Salt Lake and Lehi
- Ambassador Program Update
- Local Needs Among Utah’s Multicultural Communities During the COVID-19 Pandemic
- Campus Mobility Hub Study – APAUT Award Winner
- Does Building New Housing Reduce Overall Housing Costs?
- Layton Forward – Layton City’s Comprehensive General Plan Update
- Spring Conference Postponed, Book Club, President’s Message
- Presidents Message
- Lehi Connectivity Standards – A Stronger Urban Fabric
- Housing First; Cars Last
- UDOT Bike Infrastructure Data Collection Project
- The Great Horizon Year of 2020
- Density is a Loaded Term
- New Study on Housing Affordability Focuses on Local Land Use Practices
- There is no such thing as ‘smart sprawl’
- Legislative Interim Committee – What You Need To Know
- A bipartisan opportunity to rebuild American infrastructure
- Zoning laws aren’t the only things hindering Utah’s housing market
- Congratulations to the APAUT 2020 Award Winners
- State and Local Governments Must Further Address Housing Affordability
- The Status of Women Leaders in Government – Utah Cities and Towns
- We have to do something about Utah’s housing crisis
- What the Wasatch Front needs is more basement apartments
- Cities Don’t Need High-Rises to Become Affordable
- Away from the bustle: Covid-19 and the end of commuterland
- The Color of Law: A Book Review
- (Contract) Zoning by Agreement in Utah
- Zoning Reform Is Not Leftism
- “The Great Localization” COVID-19 and Opportunities for Communities
- Missing Middle Housing: Thinking Big and Building Small to Respond to Today’s Housing Crisis
- Zoning Reform – English Style
- 3 Stories Show the Flip Side Of Zoning Reform
- APAUT Call to Action
- The Politics of Housing Affordability
- Zoning, Affordability, and COVID-19
- Where do we go NOW!? – President’s Message
- An Interview With Ashley Cleveland, MCMP
- The Importance of Sense of Place in our Communities
- An Answer to the Suburban Growth Dilemma
- Homeless to Housed Fall 2019
- A New Initiative: Children’s Walks
- Registration Now Open for Fall Conference!